Quick Tybee Island GA MLS Search

Browse All Tybee Island GA Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$495,000
3 Beds 2 Baths SA358627 MLS Pelican's Landing BLDG.
If you’ve been waiting for a sign to live your best island life, this is it. Welcome to 26 Atlantic Avenue, Unit 201—where the vibe is high, the salt air is fresh, and the lifestyle is strictly "flip-flops only." Forget being a spectator; at this address, you’re practically the Grand Marshal. The balcony isn't just a place to sip your morning coffee (though it’s great for that, too)—it’s your private VIP lounge for Tybee’s legendary parades. Whether it’s the festive chaos of the St. Patrick's parade or the water-soaked wildness of Beach Bum, you’ll have the absolute best seat in the house. No crowds, no hovering, just you and your favorite drink watching the fun roll by. Inside, the space is getting a major glow-up. Freshly installed new flooring and a crisp coat of paint throughout, so you can move in and start living that breezy, effortless island dream from day one. It’s open and airy, making it the perfect spot for post-beach lounging or hosting a crowd before hitting the local spots. You're right in the heart of the action, so when you aren't soaking up the sun on the sand, you’re just moments away from the island’s best bites and boutiques. Ready to trade the mainland grind for Atlantic Avenue energy? Come see why life is just better at Unit 201. Your balcony throne—and your fresh new floors—are waiting.

26 Atlantic Ave Unit 201, Tybee Island

Listing courtesy of Compass Georgia.

$470,000
2 Beds 2 Baths SA358951 MLS Captains Watch Condo BLDG.
Recently Reduced! STVR ELIGIBLE! Live in the heart of Tybee Island's South Beach in this desirable Captain's Watch condominium, located just one block from the beach and only steps from Tybee's most popular restaurants, shops, nightlife, pier, pavilion, and year-round events. Whether you're looking for a personal beach retreat, full-time residence, or investment property, this condo checks all the boxes. This 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo also features a flexible sunroom that can be used as a guest room, office, or additional sleeping area, providing extra space for owners and guests alike. Sold furnished and ready to enjoy, the open living area flows to a private balcony with one of the best views in the building. Facing Butler Avenue, you'll have a front-row seat to Tybee's famous parades, festivals, and celebrations. During parade season, you'll be close enough to enjoy all the excitement from above, including the island's legendary water gun battles. Captain's Watch offers exceptional durability with all-concrete construction and hurricane-rated windows and doors. Residents and guests enjoy two elevators, a rooftop pool with ocean views, and covered parking, keeping your vehicle cooler and protected from the summer sun. Most importantly, this property is eligible for a Short-Term Vacation Rental (STVR), making it a rare opportunity for buyers seeking rental income in one of Tybee Island's most walkable and sought-after locations. With the beach just a block away and everything South Beach has to offer right outside your door, this is island living at its best. Similar units in this building are short term rented as a 3 BR.

1415 Butler Ave Unit 12, Tybee Island

Listing courtesy of ERA Wilder Realty.

$425,000
1 Beds 1 Baths SA357447 MLS Savannah Beach & Racquet Club BLDG.
Turn-Key Tybee Island Retreat with Direct Ocean Views! Whether you’re searching for a profitable Short-Term Vacation Rental, a low-maintenance full-time residence, or the perfect second home, this beautifully maintained coastal getaway checks every box. This charming 1-bedroom, 1-bath condo features a spacious bedroom with a king-sized bed, a full kitchen, and a private porch where you can relax with your morning coffee while enjoying direct ocean views and coastal breezes. Located in a gated North End Tybee Island community, enjoy beach access just steps away and resort-style amenities including two swimming pools, tennis courts, and pickleball. Spend your days relaxing by the water, watching ships pass by, and taking in breathtaking sunsets from your own piece of paradise. The unbeatable location places you within walking distance of some of Tybee’s most beloved attractions, including the Tybee Island Lighthouse, Tybee Island Marine Science Center, and Jaycee Park featuring disc golf, baseball and soccer fields, playgrounds, and scenic walking trails. Enjoy nearby local favorites such as Huc-A-Poo’s Pizza, North Beach Bar & Grill, Sea Wolf, and Zunzi’s, along with the charming boutiques and shops that make North Tybee so special. Turn Key and ready for immediate enjoyment or income production, this maintenance-free coastal retreat offers the ultimate Tybee Island lifestyle. The perfect beach getaway with everything you need just steps from your front door.

1217 Bay St Unit 221A, Tybee Island

Listing courtesy of McIntosh Realty Team LLC.

$405,000
3 Beds 2 Baths SA351607 MLS
Coastal Cottage on Tybee Island! Your Opportunity for a Coastal Lifestyle Near Back River Beach! Discover the perfect coastal getaway on Tybee Island, just steps from the serene Back River Beach. Nestled along a private drive with exclusive beach access, this charming cottage provides a unique opportunity to embrace coastal living at its finest. Property Overview • Size: 1,328 sq. ft. • Bedrooms: 3 • Bathrooms: 2 (one bath and the kitchen requires a full renovation) Renovation Opportunity: This cottage presents a fantastic chance to unleash your creativity. With complete rehab needed for one bathroom and the kitchen, you can reimagine and transform this space into your ideal coastal retreat. Enjoy Coastal Living Located only four houses from the beach, you can easily cast off in your kayak to explore Little Tybee, spend relaxing days on the beach, and enjoy breathtaking sunsets right outside your door. The cottage is situated on Chatham Avenue in the desirable Tybee Back River neighborhood, where opportunities like this rarely become available. While you are just steps from the sand and water, you will also be a short walk from Tybrisa Street's commercial and entertainment district, AJ’s, Alley #3, and the Back River Pier. Get ready to savor the coastal lifestyle and make the most of summer in your own seaside cottage.

1605 Chatham Ave Unit A, Tybee Island

Listing courtesy of Seabolt Real Estate. Selling Office: Waterline Real Estate Group.

Start Your Search

© 2026 Georgia MLS. All rights reserved. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.

Between $400K - $500K Tybee Island Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Tybee Island and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!